State Bar of Arizona says Extreme DUI not serious

View More Categories

Matthew Kelly of the law firm Kelly-McCoy PLC fails to report an Extreme DUI. Further, the Clerk of the Court never transmitted the crime to the State Bar as required by Arizona Rules of Supreme Court 61 (c)(1).

1. Conviction of a Crime. Upon conviction of a lawyer of any crime, the clerk of the court in which the conviction is entered shall, within twenty (20) days thereafter, transmit to the disciplinary clerk and to the state bar a certified copy of the judgment of conviction, and the convicted lawyer shall, within twenty (20) days after entry of judgment of conviction of a misdemeanor involving a serious crime or of any felony, provide the following information to chief bar counsel: (a) name, bar number and address of record with the state bar, and a current address if different from the address of record; (b) the name of the court in which the judgment of conviction was entered; (c) the case or file number in which the judgment of conviction was entered; and (d) the date the judgment of conviction was entered.
A. Felony Conviction. A lawyer shall be suspended after the disciplinary clerk's receipt of proof of the lawyer's conviction of a felony under either state or federal law, regardless of the pendency of post conviction motions or an appeal, unless within ten (10) days of the clerk's receipt of proof of the conviction the member files with the presiding disciplinary judge a verified motion showing good cause why the suspension should not be entered. The presiding disciplinary judge may permit the lawyer to present oral argument in support of the lawyer's motion and shall promptly grant or deny it. If the motion is denied, the lawyer shall be suspended as of the date the motion is denied. If the motion is granted, the lawyer shall not be suspended pending completion of a disciplinary proceeding based on such conviction.
B. Serious Misdemeanor Conviction. A lawyer convicted of a serious crime other than a felony may be suspended, upon motion of the state bar, pending final disposition of a disciplinary proceeding predicated upon the conviction. Within ten (10) days of the state bar filing a motion, respondent may file with the presiding disciplinary judge a verified response showing good cause why respondent should not be suspended. The presiding disciplinary judge may permit respondent to present oral argument in support of the respondent's response and shall promptly grant or deny the motion. If the motion is granted, the lawyer shall be suspended as of the date of such order.

Bar Complaint followed and they categorized an Extreme DUI as an "unfortunate event". They stated that an Extreme DUI is not a serious crime and does not need to be reported.